Teen Pregnancy Rate of Decline Slower in Rural Communities
Nov 02, 2018
Not too long ago, America braced for the digital divide. The fear was that poor urban and rural communities would not realize the advancements the digital age promised. Many still haven’t. Today, poor urban and rural communities are experiencing a different divide. This time, it’s the nation’s declining rate of teen pregnancies. Rural communities are seeing a slower rate of decline than their urban neighbors. The teen birth rate in America’s small towns is 63 percent higher than in its biggest cities, a recent government report reveals.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) points out that in 2015, there were 18.9 births for every 1,000 women between the ages of 15 and 19 living in counties with large urban areas. Conversely, there were 30.9 births for every 1,000 women in the same age group who lived in rural counties. (In 2007, there were 49.1 births for every 1,000 women ages 15 to 19 in rural communities.) Nikki Mayes, CDC spokeswoman for its Reproductive Health division in Atlanta, said the data “underscores that community can be one of the strongest predictors of pregnancy risks for teens.”
To that end, consider these statistics: Large urban communities recorded the biggest drop in teen pregnancy – 50 percent – over the last decade. Rural communities saw a decline of roughly 37 percent during the same period.
A community health issue
If community is the culprit, as Mayes indicates, why do rural communities lag urban cities when it comes to declines in the rate of teen pregnancies? It’s the usual host of suspects that rural communities sometimes lack, according to industry experts: access to health care and other necessary resources, sex ed, and an overall lack of community programs that promote prevention strategies. Rural communities that don’t address these deficits can expect to see further declines in skilled workers, increased poverty, and dependence on social services. Here are a few long-range effects of teen pregnancy that affect mom, baby and community, as published in a variety of reports.
- Teen moms are less likely to complete high school.
- Studies indicate that teen moms are three times more likely to live in poverty, compared to women who bear children in their 30s.
- Approximately two-thirds (63 percent) will depend on government assistance after giving birth.
- The clear majority will not receive formal child support, and those who do receive what amounts to a drop in the bucket compared with the actual costs of providing for a child’s essential needs.
- The Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology reports that teen mothers are likely to experience maternal anemia (associated with low birth rate and premature births); preterm delivery (at less than 37 weeks gestation); postpartum hemorrhage; and preeclampsia (high blood pressure and organ decline).
- The Journal also reports that teen moms under age 16 were twice as likely to have a forceps delivery compared with women ages 20 to 24.
A perpetuating cycle
Ofttimes, children of teen moms suffer an uphill battle. Compared to children born to older mothers, the CDC reports that children born to teen moms are more likely to:
● Drop out of high school.
● Become teen parents.
● Use Medicaid and CHIP .
● Experience abuse and neglect.
● Enter the foster care system.
● End up in prison (sons of teen moms).
● Be raised in single-parent families.
● Score lower on kindergarten readiness measures.
● Demonstrate lower vocabulary, math and reading scores.
● Experience poverty at a rate nine times higher than a child born to married adults with a high school diploma.
Community-building around teen pregnancy works
A small town in South Carolina said enough is enough. Denmark has a population just over 3,500 – similar in size to many towns in Lafayette County. At one time, Denmark had one of the highest teen pregnancy rates in the country. Over the last decade, this rural town – even with its high poverty rate – reduced teen pregnancies by more than two-thirds. They applied a few common-sense approaches to tackling pervasive teen pregnancies, and the results paid off. One central theme was equipping youths with tools to make healthy choices. In short, here’s what other rural communities can learn from Denmark.
1. Teach comprehensive sex ed. Denmark implemented a comprehensive sex ed curriculum that started with middle school students. Lessons covered self-esteem, setting sexual boundaries, and how to correctly use contraception. Individual counseling was also available to students.
2. Target messages at teen boys – not just girls. Many of the country’s teen pregnancy prevention campaigns take a one-sided approach to messaging – the primary target, girls. Developing campaigns that also target boys proved effective.
3. Get the whole community involved. Denmark’s prevention tactics extended to select shops, merchants and even churches. These venues posted prevention signage that included information about area resources. Some even handed out condoms, no questions asked.
4. Make condoms available [and] teach abstinence. Denmark partnered with several community venues that made condoms free and easily accessible. Although abstinence wasn’t a part of Denmark’s curriculum, some experts contend that it resonates with some teens, therefore making it a viable part of a well-rounded prevention program. Abstinence education offers students a definitive alternative when setting sexual boundaries and prevents sexually transmitted diseases.
5. Develop mentoring programs. Denmark paired older teens with younger teens to develop a peer mentoring program. These one-hour focus groups covered healthy relationships and safe sex, with the older teen mentors acting as educators. Peer-to-peer discussions resonated well with the younger teens and made an obvious impact. Abstinence proponents encourage that peer groups also include teens who practice abstinence.
The U.S. has the highest teen birth rate among all developed countries—double that of the United Kingdom and around four times that of Germany and France. Some blame the culture here, one that is deemed highly sexualized when it comes to images on TV and in movies. Whatever the case, rural communities are tasked with catching up with their urban counterparts when it comes to tackling teen pregnancy rates. Doing nothing burdens an already strapped health care and social service system, and perpetuates an unskilled labor force. For small, fledging towns, this will make efforts to spur economic development a moot point.